Re: Summer night dreams: advice & opinions wanted!

Judea Pearl (judea@cs.ucla.edu)
Fri, 31 Jul 1998 23:59:02 -0700 (PDT)

Dear Peter,
You asked:
For example, am I correct in suspecting that you
would reject the validity or value of "ancillary
inference netwworks" of the sort that I was trying
to describe?

I reply:
Sorry, but I have no idea what "ancillary inference networks" are.
I need to see simple compelling examples where
those networks offer new power or greater comfort.
Then I would like to see semi-formal
definitions of what the nodes-links represent, what
the input is, what questions they are designed to answer,
and what logic stands behind the answers.
The burden of explicating all these, I am afraid, lies
with those who find such networks meaningful.
Others cannot do it for you,
=========Judea